22 Comments

I love your article for two reasons. One is that it is so well researched and you produced great graphs that really convey your point.

Another is that I have also been a proponent of "Omicron is not very mild" theory and wrote several articles to the same effect.

Looking at South Africa, the deaths have just crested a few days ago, whereas cases crested over a month ago on Dec 18.

This means that a 4 week delay may be very appropriate. Omicron causes delayed deaths such as heart attacks a couple of weeks post-"recovery".

Regarding the "Omicron is mild and will end Covid" theory. My own opinion is that it is NOT very mild and it will also NOT end Covid. The other Omicron variant called Ba.2 is catching up and is already dominant in Denmark, causing further insane increase in cases curve there. Cases also stopped falling in the UK and are rising again. The reason is that the UK is a couple of weeks behind Denmark on Ba.2. We are 4 weeks behind Denmark.

https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/ba2-omicron-variant-is-worth-discussing

Most likely Ba.2 is reinfecting the recently recovered vaccinated people, giving covid on top of covid on top of booster.

Expand full comment

One of the basic truths that has seemed to evade all our 'experts' is this:

If 10% of your population has a virus, roughly 10% of your deaths will have that virus -- even if it had nothing to do with why they died.

So as the positive rate ticks up, deaths will follow because of the stupid way we count covid deaths.

Expand full comment

Someday we'll get an estimate of how many of the fatalities would have survived if not for the insane prohibition of cheap, effective early treatment? We can only hope it will result in indictments.

Expand full comment

My husband and I just recovered from covid, if recovery is defined by the dissappearance of almost all the symptoms (I have a slight residual cough) and a negative test.

We aren't vaccinated but did have some access to early treatment. We both did antigen tests to confirm infection and noted all our symptoms, which matched those typical of Omicron. A visit to our local, almost empty, ED allowed a doc to confirm that my husband's symptoms, which were worse than mine, were typical of Omicron. The doc reassured him he was doing well enough to not require medical intervention and to just manage his fever.

So I can speak from experience that the fluctuating, shifting symptoms of Omicron did follow a pattern many have reported: fevers (low grade limited to 24 hours for me--thx HCL--and 5 days going up to 103.5 for husband requiring fever reducers), fatigue, aches, some sinus issues but most of the infection focused on the throat which was wicked painful for my husban and lasted 4 days for him, milder and 1 day for me. My husband also suffered neurological disturbances which he described as "psychotic-like" attacks that were the worst part of the infection for him and unlike anything he'd ever experienced before.

I've had flu that was much worse. I've had colds that were much milder. But nothing that had pretty much laid me up for 11 days; I was able to care for us both and keep the house in order but had the also sleep ALOT. There's no way I could have gone to work, if I was employed.

To say Omicron is as mild as a cold is totally misleading. It might be, for some, but sets others up for a shock. We are both stout, never having had a flu shot and allowing our bodies the immunological training which its had plenty of experiences with in our longer lives. So we do have experiences to compare to. Like I wrote, my husband said this was the worst experience he's ever had, up there with typhoid.

Yet his O2 sats remained good, lung sound clear, color good, and while we were both fatigued, we were not debilitated to the extent we were bedridden 24/7. I do believe Omicron is milder than Delta, tending not to progress to the cytokine storm as easily, tending not to attach to lung receptors. But it was no walk in the park. And we continue to take great care to reduce the risk of long haul and of cardiac or clotting issues down the line.

Expand full comment

Can one expect that more transmissive but less severe Omicron boosts the deaths with Covid relativ to the deaths from Covid?

Expand full comment

Thank you for providing such comprehensive information! I've been reading different opinions and excellent analyses from many different sources, but these graphs hit home just a bit more than anything I've seen recently.

Expand full comment

Excellent, thanks.

Is the data available to break out these curves by vaccination status, and/or age?

Expand full comment

I must be misunderstanding your graphs because I'm interpreting a red line (deaths) sitting higher than a blue line (cases) to mean there are more deaths than cases. How can that be possible? What am I getting wrong?

Expand full comment